Home | Recipe | Pumpkin Protein Shake Starters

Pumpkin Protein Shake Starters

I’m really busy most days. Are you?

If so you know that making some of the more decadent dessert shakes can be a hassle. Take pumpkin shakes for example. You have to crack open a can of pumpkin, dole out what you need for your shake, find something to store the rest of the pumpkin. All this makes those types of shakes not feasible for when you’re on the go.

I have a solution.

Protein shake starters!

“What the HELL is a protein shake starter, Nik?”


I’m glad you asked.  I make protein shake starters so that I can quickly and easily assemble my shakes with all the flavors I love but without all the mess and time investment.

I just made up a batch of pumpkin protein shake starters and here’s how I did it:

Step One: Assemble the ingredients



So here we have a can of pumpkin, some pumpkin pie spice, some vanilla extract (or you can use some sugar-free vanilla syrup), a bowl, a wooden spoon and an ice cube tray.

Step Two: Mix it Up!



Combine the ingredients in your bowl and mix well! You want the flavors to be well distributed. Here I used the whole can of pumpkin, 1 tsp. of vanilla and 1/4 tsp. of pumpkin pie spice. You can adjust to your liking though! I did not add sweetener. I’ll add that directly to my shake if I want it.

Step Three: The ice cube tray



This is your secret weapon in this whole deal. The one thing that always irked me about pumpkin shakes was feeling like I had to figure out what to do with the rest of that can of pumpkin. Well, once you mix up your starter, fill an empty ice cube tray with it, using a tablespoon measure. On a standard ice cube tray this should get you perfect, one ounce servings of your pumpkin mixture. Remember to tap down your ice cube tray on the counter to make sure it settles in there nice.

Step Four: Freeze!


Then all you have to do is pop it in the freezer and freeze until solid. When they’re done, you pop them out of the ice cube tray and into some freezer bags (I recommend getting smaller bags and only putting a few in each bag).

Then when you’re ready to make your shake, combine your shake starter (two cubes) with milk (or water, if that’s your thing), protein powder and any other flavor additives you like (additional sugar-free syrups, etc.) and away you go!

These starters take about 10 minutes to make but they save you time and money. Now that you have your canned pumpkin all prepped to become a shake, and now that you have it all frozen (so it lasts longer) you waste less pumpkin and you can mix up your pumpkin pie shake in no time!

And it’s automatic portion control. Remember, generally one ice cube slot = one ounce.

I make protein shake starters out of all sorts of stuff. Look for more combinations to come!

Pumpkin Protein Shake Starters
Print Recipe
    Pumpkin Protein Shake Starters
    Print Recipe
      Share this Recipe

      7 comments

      1. Wendy

        What an awesome idea! I am stealing this one!

      2. Nikki Massie

        Stealing is totally allowed! Just be sure to share the idea with others! (and a little linkback love is always nice too)

      3. NJ Weight Loss Surgeon

        Pumpkin flavored ANYTHING is always good around this time – considering it's it has nutritional value for weight loss surgery patients. This was very creative. Thanks for sharing!

      4. Kates

        This may or may not have been pinned on my Protein Drinks board on Pinterest…just saying 😉

      5. Anonymous

        @ Kates.. the spice combination exactly is probably uniquely Foodies which I will for sure be making! The idea of the ice cube tray well, I am nearly 60 years old and have been doing this for nearly 30 years. I don't think even you can take credit for that, my mother did it too! Thats where I learned the trick.

      6. Nikki Massie

        🙂 I take credit for nothing except having done it for a while now. I certainly didn't invent the idea, I just share it!

      7. will glennon

        Great advice about the Pumpkin Protein Shake Starters is useful for healthy life. The protein shake helps you recover after the workout, without taking in carbs which are an energy source. increasing your protein intake is a good way to loose body fat.
        ——————————————
        whey protein powder

      Leave a Reply

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *